metal roofs over shingles

Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles

Weighing the pros and cons of a new roof is an important first step for residential homeowners. Purchasing a new roof is an investment, and a hefty one at that, so it’s important to complete your due diligence prior to hiring a reliable roofing contractor. One of the first items of business is understanding the different components of a roof and how they work together. The material will play a crucial role in price and lifespan. Two of the most popular styles of roofs are metal and shingles. So let’s take a closer look at metal roof vs asphalt shingles.

Looking for new residential roofing services? B&M Roofing offers experts and quality roofs for homeowners throughout Colorado. It can be an overwhelming process, so be sure to check out our blog breaking down all of the roofing basics.

asphalt shingles roof

Installing a New Roof

If it’s time for a new roof, note that it may take some time to research and determine the best path forward. One of the most overwhelming aspects of homeownership is the ongoing costs of maintenance and upkeep. However, making the right moves can help save a ton of money in the long run. For example, selecting quality workmanship for a new roof can make a world of difference to the lifespan of the end product, therefore, cutting costs for repairs and new replacements later down the road.

Be sure to carefully select a roofing contractor, as all are not created equal. Here are some tips you should consider before hiring a Colorado roofing contractor. Aside from this, it’s also important to determine your home needs.

Selecting Materials

One of the most important items of business when selecting a new roof is the materials that will be used. On one hand, most homeowners have a preference for materials due to their aesthetics and outward appearance. However, more important items should also be taken into account such as:

  • Roof Structure
  • Product cost
  • Material weight
  • Installation Requirements
  • Environment/Weather factors

You may notice that different regions of the US feature various styles of roofing. Considering the weather patterns is a huge determining factor. Some roofing materials are more durable than others under certain circumstances. Colorado, in particular, is prone to heavy snow, rain, and even hail. For this reason, metal roofs can be considered a more ideal material to use. However, there are pros and cons to every type of material. Are asphalt shingles a close secondary option?

metal roof vs. asphalt shingles

Metal Roof vs Asphalt Shingles

Consider the various pros and cons of a metal roof vs. asphalt shingles. Determine needs for your home, weather patterns, and upkeep. Also, figure out the best look for your home as it will be an enjoyment for years to come. In all, roofing materials should come backed with a manufacture warranty, and you should only consider working with Colorado roofers that offer workmanship warranties, as well.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles have a variety of benefits, especially in consideration of their application and variety of looks. In fact, newer asphalt shingles can be made to look more like tile, wood shake, and slate, which gives homeowners more of a variety to select from. Asphalt shingles are the most common material used in the United States for roofs, likely due to their low cost and durability. They’re also easier to install than other selections.


Quick to install, economically affordable, comes in a variety of colors/styles


Shorter lifespan, quality varies

Metal Roof

One of the most durable materials to choose for your home roof is metal. Fortunately, metal combats the most drastic weather conditions and is suitable for colder climates like that in Colorado. Additionally, metal roofs can come in various colors to match your home style. However, the downside is that metal roofs are difficult to install and can be very expensive. For hail prone Colorado, though, most homeowners select this material as their preferred option.


Durable, long lifespan, reliable, comes in a variety of colors


Expensive, difficult to install, short-term future may not be worth the investment.

metal roofing colorado

Metal roof over shingles

Metal roofs are far more durable than almost any other option, withstanding much of Colorado’s extreme weather. These roofs have been known to last 50-60 years (and sometimes even longer) without any issues. That durability costs homeowners upfront: In most cases, metal roofing can cost two to four times as much as traditional shingles per square foot, though that number can be much higher if you opt for high-end copper or zinc roofing.

Choosing between shingles or a metal roof ultimately comes down to how much you’re willing to invest and how long you plan on staying in your home. If you plan to stick around for a while, a metal roof is well worth your investment, but if you have plans to sell in the short-term future, going with asphalt shingles is a safe and wise decision that remains popular for good reason.

Final Decision: Metal Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles

The final decision is ultimately up to the homeowner. Discuss quality and workmanship with your roofing contractor and obtain free estimates for your upcoming project. Be sure to do research upfront to get a full scope of needs/requirements for your home in addition to obtaining critical information for upkeep and maintenance.

B&M Roofing offers a wide variety of styles and options for residential roofing. Give us a call today for a free estimate at (303) 443-5843.